The Adaptable Educator’s Book Review – Amphigorey by Edward Gorey

Amphigorey by Edward Gorey is not merely an anthology of illustrated absurdities; it is a masterclass in gothic minimalism, an invitation to probe the margins of narrative coherence and the black comedy that resides in the interstices. First assembled in 1972, this collection of twenty early books and pamphlets showcases Gorey’s distinctive blend of Victorian pastiche, wry humor, and existential unease.

---

1. Text and Image in Tension

At the heart of Amphigorey lies the dialectic between word and image. Gorey’s spare captions—often terse couplets or single declarative sentences—function less as exegesis and more as ironic counterpoint to his meticulously cross‑hatched scenes. In The Gashlycrumb Tinies, for example, the deceptively playful “E is for Ernest who choked on a peach” both mirrors and undercuts the deadpan tableau of a genteel child in mid-fall. The text’s laconic tone amplifies the visual horror, turning each alphabetic vignette into a miniature parable on the capriciousness of fate.

---

2. Gothic Comedy and the Absence of Resolution

Gorey’s worlds are populated by a gallery of characters—children, governesses, mysterious creatures—who drift in undefined spaces, subject to cruel misadventures. Unlike traditional gothic tales with clear moral or supernatural explanations, Amphigorey revels in ambiguity. The melancholic visitor of The Doubtful Guest arrives without introduction and departs without farewell, leaving its hosts (and the reader) suspended in a deliciously unresolved anxiety. This refusal to resolve tension aligns Gorey with postmodern aesthetics, wherein the very act of withholding an ending becomes a narrative strategy.

---

3. Intertextual Resonances

While Gorey’s penmanship evokes the woodcuts of Aubrey Beardsley, his thematic playground recalls Edward Lear’s nonsense verse and Lewis Carroll’s dream‑logic. Yet Gorey diverges by locating his humor in the grotesque rather than the whimsical. A governess in The Sinking Spell is swallowed whole by a nightmarish vortex, a scenario less charm‑filled than Lear’s limericks and more akin to the startling reversals in E. T. A. Hoffmann. Through these echoes, Amphigoreybecomes an intertextual palimpsest: Victorian gravitas meets mid‑century surrealism.

---

4. The Aesthetics of Wabi‑Sabi and Impermanence

Beneath the surface whimsy, there lies a profound meditation on impermanence. Gorey’s monochrome artistry—its fine lines and generous negative spaces—speaks to a beauty found in decay and incompletion. Objects tilt, rooms sag, and characters seem to materialize from thin air, only to vanish or suffer off‑page calamities. This embrace of the unfinished moment resonates with the Japanese concept of wabi‑sabi: an appreciation of transience and the elegance of the incomplete.

---

5. Scholarly Implications and Quotidian Terror

For the literary scholar, Amphigorey offers fertile terrain in semiotics and genre study. Its minimalist narratives defy conventional plot arcs, suggesting instead a cyclical universe of arbitrary cruelty. Scholars might ask: How does Gorey’s strategic withholding of backstory amplify readerly projection? In what ways do his characters’ furtive glances and static poses function as metatextual invitations to speculate? And how does the very absence of moral resolution subvert the didactic impulse of earlier children’s literature?

Amphigorey is, in essence, a textual and visual Rorschach test—its inkblots shaped by Gorey’s wit and our own predispositions toward order or chaos. To consume it is to enter a realm where the horrific and the hilarious coexist in delicate equipoise, where the shadows on the page suggest hidden narratives we ourselves supply. For those willing to linger over each frame, to read between the lines as much as within them, Edward Gorey’s Amphigorey remains an enduring testament to the power of absence, ambiguity, and the macabre jocularity that lurks beneath genteel façades.